New Jersey has at least 25 categories of places where law-abiding citizens can't carry a firearm. New York has 20 — including houses of worship. California has 29, covering banks, athletic facilities, and any "public gathering." Maryland added public parks, restaurants, museums, stadiums, and thousands of acres of state forests to its list.
Justice Clarence Thomas just told all of them he's counting.
The Supreme Court declined on Monday to hear Novotny v. Moore, a Second Amendment challenge to Maryland's sweeping carry restrictions. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals had upheld most of those restrictions back in January, and the Court let that decision stand — for now. But Thomas filed a statement that read less like a procedural note and more like a warning shot, as reported by The Gateway Pundit.
Thomas wrote that he harbors "serious doubts that our Nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation supports many of these sweeping restrictions." He pointed to the cumulative effect of Maryland's location bans — public demonstrations, public transportation, restaurants, alcohol-serving establishments, healthcare facilities, amusement parks — and concluded that "their cumulative effect is to prohibit firearms wherever people gather for eating, drinking, recreation, amusement, and [free speech] — an affront to the right of 'law-abiding citizens.'"
That phrase "cumulative effect" is doing a lot of work. Maryland didn't ban guns in one dramatic swoop. It banned them in one place, then another, then another, until the right to carry outside your home existed mostly on paper. Thomas sees the pattern. He wrote that expanding "sensitive places" to this degree would "eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense."
The backdrop here matters. In June 2026, the Supreme Court struck down a Hawaii law requiring permission to carry a concealed firearm — with all three liberal justices dissenting. In March 2025, the Court upheld Biden-era ghost gun regulations, with Thomas and Justice Samuel Alito dissenting. And on December 2, the Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments on semiautomatic firearm bans. The Trump administration has filed briefs supporting Second Amendment challenges.
So the Court didn't take this Maryland case. Blue state attorneys general will call that a win. They shouldn't.
What Thomas did was lay out, in writing, exactly why these laws fail under New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen — the landmark 2022 decision requiring gun regulations to be consistent with the nation's historical tradition. He named the states. He named the categories. He showed his math. That's not a justice venting frustration. That's a justice building a record for the next case the Court does take.
Maryland, New Jersey, New York, California, Illinois — they all responded to Bruen by trying to regulate around it. Ban carry in enough individual locations and you've effectively banned carry everywhere without technically overturning the ruling. Thomas just told them the workaround has an expiration date.
The oral arguments on semiautomatic bans are seventeen days away.

