Democrats Can't Beat the Electoral College, So Now They're Trying to Kill It

Eighteen states and the District of Columbia have now signed onto the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact — an agreement that would hand their electoral votes to whoever wins the national popular vote, regardless of how their own citizens voted. Five more states could join in the coming months, potentially pushing the compact past the 270 electoral vote threshold needed to take effect.

They don't need a constitutional amendment. They just need enough states to agree to ignore their own voters.

The blue wave of 2026 cracked the door wide open. As Just The News chief political correspondent Ben Whedon reported, the compact's path to 270 now runs through five newly blue or newly accessible states: Arizona, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. Each requires passage through both legislative chambers and a gubernatorial signature — or a veto override. With Democrat David Crowley winning the governor's mansion in Wisconsin, Democrat Josh Shapiro already seated in Pennsylvania, and Mikie Sherrill freshly inaugurated in New Jersey, the math suddenly looks very different.

Sherrill made the quiet part loud when she argued for the compact: "Our votes in New Jersey are worth about one fifth of what a vote in Wyoming is. That's not democracy."

That framing — small states have too much power, the system is unfair — is the entire sales pitch. It conveniently ignores why the Electoral College exists in the first place. The Founders designed a system where presidential candidates had to build broad coalitions across diverse states, not just run up the score in the five biggest metro areas. Article II, Section 1, Clause 2 of the Constitution grants state legislatures the power to appoint electors. The compact exploits that grant by turning it into a weapon against the very federalism it was meant to protect.

Attorney General Todd Blanche isn't buying it. "It shouldn't get past the district court," Blanche said of the compact's legal viability, adding, "I am optimistic that the Supreme Court will never even have to deal with this." The legal argument against the compact centers on Article I, Section 10, Clause 3 — the Compact Clause — which requires congressional consent for interstate agreements that alter the political balance between states and the federal government. The compact has no such consent.

Inez Feltscher Stepman, senior policy and legal analyst at the Independent Women's Forum, has pointed to existing case law that complicates the compact's enforceability. The Supreme Court ruled in Chiafolo v. Washington that states can bind their electors, but Miller v. Washington in 2019 raised questions about the outer limits of that authority. The compact asks states to bind their electors not to the will of their own voters, but to voters in other states entirely — a step no court has endorsed.

The popular-vote-loser argument is the compact's emotional engine, and it runs on two data points: George W. Bush over Hillary Clinton's predecessor Al Gore in 2000, and Donald Trump over Hillary Clinton in 2016. Before the 21st century, it happened exactly three times — 1824, 1876, 1888. John Quincy Adams won over Andrew Jackson in 1824, and that outcome was decided by the House of Representatives under rules so different from modern elections that the comparison barely holds. Two elections in twenty years became the constitutional crisis that justifies rewriting how we pick presidents.

What the compact's advocates conspicuously never address is what happens when a state's own voters go one way and the national popular vote goes another. A Republican voter in Pennsylvania watches her state vote Republican, then watches Pennsylvania's electors go to the Democrat because California and New York tipped the national number. The compact's architects have no answer for her because she isn't the voter they're designing the system for.

The compact needs 270 to activate. It doesn't have 270 yet. But five state legislatures are now in play, and the governors who would sign the bills are already in office.

The last time the rules produced a result Democrats didn't like, they spent four years calling it illegitimate. Now they're trying to make sure the rules can never produce that result again.


Most Popular

Most Popular