A New Jersey theater company called Busted Broadway posted a casting call on Playbill this Wednesday for a production titled "George Floyd the Musical." By Thursday, Playbill Chairman Philip Birsh and Chief Operating Officer Alex Birsh were issuing public apologies, calling the listing "hateful" and yanking it from the site.
The production made it all the way from concept to casting call before a single adult in the room asked whether this was a good idea.
Busted Broadway, which launched in May 2026, describes itself as an independent musical theater record label. Their defense of the project was immediate and, somehow, earnest. "Our George Floyd the Musical is not making light of, condoning, or mocking the horrific 2020 murder of George Floyd," the company said in a statement. "It's a satire on the culture, rather than the person."
Satire on the culture. That's one way to describe putting jazz hands on a man's death in Minneapolis police custody — a death that launched months of riots, billions in property damage, and an entire political movement. George Floyd died in May 2020 after an encounter over a counterfeit $20 bill. Six years later, someone decided that story needed choreography.
Playbill's leadership didn't mince — actually, they did. Philip and Alex Birsh released a joint statement dripping with the kind of corporate anguish that only surfaces after the internet has already decided you're guilty. "We're terribly crestfallen that our system to catch inappropriate and offensive submissions failed," they wrote. Crestfallen. That's the word they went with.
The apology continued: "We apologize unequivocally for giving this hateful listing any further air, and we promise to do better going forward." The listing, according to Just The News, was live for less than 24 hours before leadership was "alerted" and removed it.
What's worth noting is who objected and why. The backlash wasn't partisan. Conservatives saw the obvious grotesqueness of turning a man's death into a Broadway-adjacent spectacle. But the louder outrage came from the left — the same cultural establishment that painted Floyd murals on buildings, named streets after him, and spent two years treating any criticism of the canonization as borderline criminal. "This is in incredibly poor taste. This isn't edgy," read one widely shared response from within the theater community itself.
The people who built the George Floyd mythology are now policing who gets to use it. The iconography was fine when it served a political purpose — when it justified defunding police departments, when it anchored a Vice Presidential nominee's national profile, when it turned a Minneapolis intersection into a permanent memorial. But the moment someone outside the approved channels tries to do something with the same material, it's "hateful."
Busted Broadway's defense — that the show satirizes the culture, not the person — is actually the most honest thing anyone involved has said. The culture around George Floyd's death became its own industry. Merchandise. Murals. Foundation money. Speaking tours. A musical was always the logical next step. Someone just said the quiet part out loud.
Playbill promised to do better. The casting call lasted one day. The cultural machinery that made it inevitable has been running for six years.

